ALL TOOLS AND SCRIPT FOR FREE

๐Ÿ” The real deal with review gating

Good morning search marketers, more is better.

At least when it comes to reviews. Review gating, or the process of steering unsatisfied customers away from submitting reviews to third-party sites, was once a somewhat common practice. Yelp and Google have banned selective review solicitation, but did the practice work in the first place? A new study says, No.

The study by GatherUp looked at whether review gating had an impact on star ratings. The findings? Review gating had little impact on star ratings, and, in aggregate, businesses without review gating in place received significantly higher review volumes.

We know review volume matters for local rankings. We also know that consumers often don't trust businesses with perfect ratings. If you're working with a vendor that is using review gating, you should ask the vendor to stop or look elsewhere. 

Before you get on with your day, we've just opened up our Amazon Advertising survey and we'd love it if you'd help us gather data. Last year we found that 80% of respondents advertising on platforms that support digital commerce campaigns planned to increase spending in 2019. And nearly half said they planned to increase spending on Amazon by more than 25%. 

Please click here to answer this year's survey, it will only take 10 minutes and you'll be entered into a drawing for a free ticket to any SMX West event in the next 2 years. 

Read on for a Pro Tip from Google and Bing on their disavow tools.

Ginny Marvin
Editor-In-Chief

 
 
 
Pro Tip
 

Does the disavow tool work for algorithm penalties or is it mostly for manual action?

"The disavow tools from Bing and Google most definitely help with manual spam actions," explains Bing's Frรฉdรฉric Dubut and ex-Googler Fili Wiese who will both be sharing new insights at SMX East. "In fact, it is crucial to resolve link related manual spam actions/penalties with the disavow tool. At the same time, if your website has a history of active link building, the disavow tools are also a great way of getting rid of those low-quality links that you can't remove and are now in violation of the Google or Bing Webmaster Guidelines. While there is no such thing as algorithmic penalties from Google's side, disavow link data will be used by both Bing and Google as a potential data point for testing the various algorithms that power rankings."

More on penalties »

 

Webinar: How to Deliver Effective Account-Based Marketing

Join our panel of experts as they show you how to implement successful account-based strategies with limited resources. You'll learn how to use pre-targeting to quickly test thousands of variables in order to reach the most efficient lead generation strategy, and how artificial intelligence (AI) can improve your campaign targeting and timeliness across channels.

Register now... »

 
Search Shorts
 

BERT scores? Nope.

BERT Scores. No, there are no BERT scores or values assigned to specific pages, BERT doesn't work that way, says Danny Sullivan of Google.

Google Discover referrer. Google has no plans to give a referrer to Google Discover-specific traffic, Google did give us Search Console discover reports, said John Mueller of Google.

Halloween Doodle. Did you see the Google Halloween Doodle? If not, check it out over here.

 

[Survey] Want To Be A Search Engine Land MVP Subscriber?

Are you a loyal Search Engine Land reader? Have you ever shared this newsletter with a friend or colleague? Do you love free swag like travel mugs and tote bags? Take our three-question survey now!

Begin the survey »

 
 
 
What We're Reading
 

We've curated our picks from across the web so you can retire your feed reader

A call for the next big ideas in news – Google Blog

Disowning the Disavow Tool – DealerOn

Get your products in front of holiday shoppers – Google Blog

Google Maps Shows Business Short Names – Search Engine Roundtable

Google testing drastically redesigned Assistant Updates feed – 9to5Google

How to Increase Business Visibility with Google Posts – Location3 Media

Tales of Horror from the Dark Side of Google My Business – BrightLocal